Response to Professor Edmar Bacha’s critical note on “Is Brazilian premature deindustrialization a case of Dutch disease?”
Main Article Content
Abstract
This Note responds to Bacha’s critical comments on our paper “Is Brazilian Premature Deindustrialization a Case of Dutch Disease?”, which was published in the Brazilian Journal of Political Economy (Nassif, Feijó and Araújo, 2026). However, since we believe that his critique was prompted by the brief critical remarks we made regarding the paper he co-authored in the Revista Brasileira de Economia (Bacha et al., 2025), we also demonstrate that the latter study suffers from several methodological shortcomings that preclude drawing robust conclusions about the causes of premature deindustrialization in Brazil, let alone about its association with the Dutch disease phenomenon.
JEL Classification: O1; O47; O49.