Fixed income ETFs or “Tesouro Direto” What is better for the individual investor?

Main Article Content

Gustavo Silva Araujo
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8078-6565
Leonardo Tadeu Sanches Chaves
https://orcid.org/0009-0003-7306-7206

Abstract

This article evaluates which fixed income investment is more advantageous for individual investors: government bonds purchased through the Tesouro Direto (TD) platform or fixed income Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs). The analysis compares ETFs that track a benchmark index with TD bond portfolios matched by duration, taking into account various costs such as management fees, brokerage fees, and tax implications. The findings show that ETFs with an average portfolio reset term (PMC) longer than 720 days — and therefore subject to the lowest income tax rate — deliver superior net performance compared to TD bond portfolios. Conversely, when the benchmark is the policy interest rate (PMC of 1 day), TD portfolios outperform. Taxation is a key factor in this comparison: capital gains and losses within ETFs can be offset for tax purposes, unlike TD investments, and reinvestment of redemption proceeds in ETFs does not trigger immediate taxation.

Article Details

How to Cite
Araujo, G. S., & Chaves, L. T. S. (2025). Fixed income ETFs or “Tesouro Direto”: What is better for the individual investor?. Brazilian Review of Finance, 23(1), e202516. https://doi.org/10.12660/rbfin.v23n1.2025.94017
Section
Papers
Author Biographies

Gustavo Silva Araujo, Banco Central do Brasil, Brazil

Banco Central do Brasil, Brazil

Leonardo Tadeu Sanches Chaves, FGV EPGE, Brazil

FGV EPGE, Brazil

References

ANBIMA (2025) Estatísticas: Varejo, private e gestores de patrimônio. Available at: https://www.anbima.com.br/pt_br/informar/estatisticas/varejo-private-e-gestores-de-patrimonio/varejo-consolidado-mensal.htm

B3 (2025) Perfil de investidores pessoas físicas. Available at: https://www.b3.com.br/pt_br/market-data-e-indices/servicos-de-dados/market-data/consultas/mercado-a-vista/perfil-pessoas-fisicas/perfil-pessoa-fisica/

Ben-David, I., Franzoni, F. and Moussawi, R. (2017) Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs). Annual Review of Financial Economics, 9. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3386/w22829

Bogle, J. (2002) An index fund fundamentalist. Journal of Portfolio Management, 28, pp. 31-38. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3905/jpm.2002.319840

BTG Pactual (2024) Ações -- renda variável. Available at: https://investimentos.btgpactual.com/renda-variavel/acoes/

Choi, J. J. and Robertson, A. Z. (2020) What matters to individual investors? Evidence from the horse's mouth. The Journal of Finance, 75(4). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jofi.12895

Ettore, L. A. and Maia, V. (2017) Fundos de renda fixa: Uma análise sob as perspectivas do pequeno investidor. Revista de Contabilidade, Ciência da Gestão e Finanças, 5(2), pp. 25-49.

Genial Investimentos (2024) Custos e tarifas. Available at: https://www.genialinvestimentos.com.br/custos-tarifas/

Litterman, R. B. and Scheinkman, J. A. (1991) Common factors affecting bond returns. Journal of Fixed Income, 1(1), pp. 54-61. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3905/jfi.1991.692347

Nunes, R. V. and Sales, G. A. W. (2020) Viabilidade da alocação de recursos em fundos de investimentos de renda fixa em relação ao Tesouro Direto. Brazilian Journal of Development, 6(9), pp. 65089-65108. DOI: https://doi.org/10.34117/bjdv6n9-080

Tesouro Direto (2024) Preços e taxas. Available at: https://www.tesourodireto.com.br/titulos/precos-e-taxas.htm#0

XP Investimentos (2024) Custos operacionais. Available at: https://www.xpi.com.br/custos-operacionais/

Yoshinaga, C. and Eid-Junior, W. (2019) Perspectivas para os ETFs no Brasil. Artigo de pesquisa, FGV - Centro de Estudos em Finanças.