Evaluating public programs: methodological and conceptual challenges
Main Article Content
Abstract
This paper emphasizes the importance of evaluating public programs, considering the acuteness of the fiscal crisis, the lack of public sector funding, and the indispensable government intervention in order to meet the needs of the underprivileged. Systematic, continuous and effective evaluation is a
powerful managerial tool, allowing policymakers and program managers to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of social program funding. The paper discusses the conceptual maze that still prevails in this field, revealed by the multiple concepts that can be applied, by the different types of evaluation and by the variety of criteria presented by specialists. Criteria application,
on the other hand, requires specific operational forms, known as social indicators, whose definition is not unanimous either. Evaluation is a set of techniques which use distinctive concepts often to refer to the same procedures. Therefore, until there is some progress in theorizing the practice and finding the necessary consensus for the construction of conceptual paradigms every evaluation effort will require the previous establishment of a reference framework for analysis and supervised personnel training. Experienced professionals may adopt this procedure for consultancies, but not all technical personnel can undertake this job without making evaluation even
more difficult. But neither difficulties nor risks should be an overwhelming obstacle for trying to apply such methodology systematically. After all, this is a field — such as many others in administration — in which learning with practice contributes for overcoming conceptual and operational hindrances.
powerful managerial tool, allowing policymakers and program managers to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of social program funding. The paper discusses the conceptual maze that still prevails in this field, revealed by the multiple concepts that can be applied, by the different types of evaluation and by the variety of criteria presented by specialists. Criteria application,
on the other hand, requires specific operational forms, known as social indicators, whose definition is not unanimous either. Evaluation is a set of techniques which use distinctive concepts often to refer to the same procedures. Therefore, until there is some progress in theorizing the practice and finding the necessary consensus for the construction of conceptual paradigms every evaluation effort will require the previous establishment of a reference framework for analysis and supervised personnel training. Experienced professionals may adopt this procedure for consultancies, but not all technical personnel can undertake this job without making evaluation even
more difficult. But neither difficulties nor risks should be an overwhelming obstacle for trying to apply such methodology systematically. After all, this is a field — such as many others in administration — in which learning with practice contributes for overcoming conceptual and operational hindrances.
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
Article Details
How to Cite
Costa, F. L. da, & Castanhar, J. C. (2003). Evaluating public programs: methodological and conceptual challenges. Brazilian Journal of Public Administration, 37(5), 969 a 992. Retrieved from https://periodicos.fgv.br/rap/article/view/6509
Issue
Section
Article
RAP is committed to contributing to the protection of the author's intellectual rights. In this regard, it:
- Adopts the Creative Commons Attribution BY 4.0 license, which allows articles to be reused and distributed without restriction, provided that the original work is properly cited;
- Ensures moral and usage rights of the article to authors, in accordance with Creative Commons Attribution BY 4.0. Authors retain the copyright to the published article, and the journal holds the right of first publication;
- Utilizes content similarity/plagiarism detection software (Crossref Similarity Check);
- Recommends the use of CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) authorship criteria;
- Adopts actions to combat plagiarism and ethical misconduct, aligned with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines;
- Reserves the right to make changes to the original versions regarding normative, spelling, and grammatical standards to maintain high linguistic quality and layout standardization, while respecting the authors' style. Subsequently, authors will receive the final versions for approval prior to publication.
Further information on the Code of Ethics adopted by RAP can be found in Ethical Standards and Code of Conduct.